I haven't read anything by McMaster yet, but was impressed by his talk at Stoicon X Military a few years ago. Got the impression that he's a true professional, committed to doing the hard things for the right reasons.
Ack but I won't stand on ad hominen. Massimo himself said he would be challenged in Stockdale's boots. Agree or disagree with his position, his work deserves respect.
I respect Stockdale’s work more than any academic.
As for quitting when it’s distasteful or one comes across dishonesty- we’d have no military in days. Except for the ones that are utterly indifferent to Honor.
As it happens DOD 🇺🇸 is well on the way to getting just so soldiers... so the academics can see a sort of purity in action at last.
The Khmer Rouge violently massacred a quarter of Cambodia's entire population in their killing fields. How is it "being a Stoic" to just let mass murder happen with impunity?
I find myself currently reading Dereliction of Duty by H R McMaster, which I highly recommend.
I haven't read anything by McMaster yet, but was impressed by his talk at Stoicon X Military a few years ago. Got the impression that he's a true professional, committed to doing the hard things for the right reasons.
Tell Massismo he’s a poseur and Stockdale was the real thing.
This is the kindest response I can with Epic restraint muster.
I am no Stoic.
Ack but I won't stand on ad hominen. Massimo himself said he would be challenged in Stockdale's boots. Agree or disagree with his position, his work deserves respect.
I like your restraint.
I respect Stockdale’s work more than any academic.
As for quitting when it’s distasteful or one comes across dishonesty- we’d have no military in days. Except for the ones that are utterly indifferent to Honor.
As it happens DOD 🇺🇸 is well on the way to getting just so soldiers... so the academics can see a sort of purity in action at last.
Oh I should add - it is less ad hominem and more a blanket condemnation of academia and the words not deeds sort.
If it weren't for my degree in Applied Uselessness, I might never have joined up.
🤣
Weaponize it.
Tell me a degree, I will demonstrate weaponizing.
Yours or pick one, such as underwater basket weaving
The Khmer Rouge violently massacred a quarter of Cambodia's entire population in their killing fields. How is it "being a Stoic" to just let mass murder happen with impunity?